Classic Cucumber Tea Sandwiches Light Lemonherb

Q: Can I make Cucumber Sandwiches ahead of time for a party?

You can assemble them and keep chilled for 1–2 hours before serving without much loss of texture, which is handy for afternoon tea or a picnic. For longer prep, make the lemon‑herb butter and slice the cucumbers in advance (drain and pat dry, then refrigerate in a single layer between paper towels), and only butter and assemble the bread shortly before guests arrive. Avoid freezing assembled sandwiches — they’ll become watery and lose their delicate texture.

Q: What are easy variations or substitutions for Classic Cucumber Tea Sandwiches?

For a simple twist, swap the lemon‑herb butter for soft cream cheese mixed with dill or chives, or add smoked salmon and capers for a richer tea‑time treat. Vegan or lighter options work well: try vegan butter or a whipped herbed yogurt (or strained Greek yogurt) and whole‑grain or gluten‑free bread. You can also tweak herbs — chives, tarragon or parsley all play nicely with cucumber if you don’t have fresh dill.

Classic LemonHerb Cucumber Sandwiches My GoTo Tea Sandwiches

By Fia MartinezSeptember 16, 2025

Jump to Recipe

5.00 (1 Ratings)

Table of Contents

☷

Recipe Introduction

Quick Hook

Cucumber Sandwiches are my go-to light bite for almost everything. Ever had a sandwich that felt like a cool breeze? Oh my gosh, this one does that.

I fold lemon and dill into butter for a bright finish. It tastes fresh and slightly tangy. People call these Cucumber Tea Sandwiches at proper teas.

Brief Overview

These are Classic British Tea Sandwiches by origin. They grew from afternoon rituals into proper tea party food. Difficulty is easy for most cooks.

Prep is bold Prep Time: 20 minutes active plus 15 minutes passive . No cooking required. Total time is 35 minutes .

This recipe yields 6 full sandwiches. That equals 12 finger sandwiches for afternoon tea. Serve on a chilled platter with Earl Grey.

Main Benefits

Top health perk is lightness and low calories. Cucumber slices add hydration and fresh crunch. This is perfect for Tea Party Sandwiches and appetizer sandwiches.

It’s also great for Easy Picnic Finger Foods. What makes it special is the lemon herb butter. The butter lifts the cucumber without drowning it.

I once made a batch for a garden brunch. Guests kept coming back for more. My gran used to say Tea fixes everything.

That stuck with me.

These are also great as Vegetarian Tea Sandwich Recipes. Swap herbs or bread for small twists. They work as classy finger sandwiches for afternoon tea.

Presentation is effortless but looks elegant. If you want Lemon Herb Cucumber Sandwiches, this is the version to try. Want a fancier take? Add microgreens or thin lemon rounds.

I faced one small challenge first time. Cucumbers made the bread soggy. The fix was simple. Salt slices and blot them dry.

Chill sandwiches before cutting for clean edges. These tips keep them neat for serving.

Now let’s move smoothly into the ingredient list. The next section shows exact amounts. Get your mandoline, bread, and fresh cucumber ready.

Main Ingredients

For the Lemon Herb Butter

Unsalted butter, softened: 6 tbsp (85 g) .
Fresh lemon juice: 1 tsp (5 ml) .
Lemon zest: 1/2 tsp (about 1 g) .
Fresh dill or chives, finely chopped: 2 tbsp (8 10 g) .
Fine sea salt: 1/4 tsp (1.5 g) .
Freshly ground black pepper: light crackling ( about 1/8 tsp ).

For the Sandwiches

White sandwich bread, thin sliced: 12 slices (about 360 g) .
English cucumber: 1 large (about 10 12 oz / 280 340 g) .
Fine sea salt (for drawing moisture): 1/4 1/2 tsp (1.5 3 g) .
Optional garnish: thin lemon slices or microgreens.

I love making these Cucumber Sandwiches for friends. Honestly, they feel fancy and take ten minutes. Quick stat: plan 2 3 finger sandwiches per guest . That helps at tea parties.

Seasoning Notes

Essential combos: lemon plus dill is classic. Salt and pepper are musts. A light lemon tang brightens everything. For a richer version use cream cheese and dill.

Flavor enhancers: a tiny pinch of sugar balances lemon. A smear of softened butter locks moisture away. Microgreens add a peppery bite.

Aromatics: fresh dill, chives, or tarragon. Use fresh herbs for best flavor. Dried herbs are weaker. Use about half the amount if dried.

Quick substitutions: no dill? Use chives or parsley. No butter? Use cream cheese or mayo mixed with lemon. For vegans, use a herbed vegan spread.

These swaps keep them great as Vegetarian Tea Sandwich Recipes or Vegan Cucumber Sandwiches .

Equipment Needed

Essentials only:

Mandoline or very sharp chef’s knife.
Mixing bowl and small spatula.
Cutting board and serrated knife.
Paper towels or a clean kitchen towel.
Plate, plastic wrap, and a tray.
Rolling pin (optional for flattening bread).

Common household alternatives: no mandoline? Use a sharp knife and patience. No rolling pin? Use a wine bottle. No plastic wrap? A clean plate pressed on top works.

I once forgot to blot cucumbers. Disaster. Soggy sandwiches. Lesson learned. Chill the sandwiches 10 15 minutes before cutting.

That tip gives neat edges every time. These are perfect as Cucumber Tea Sandwiches , Tea Party Food , and Easy Picnic Finger Foods .

Cooking Method

Classic Cucumber Tea Sandwiches Light Lemonherb presentation

I love how simple Cucumber Sandwiches are. Afternoon tea really took off in Britain in the 1840s. That old-school charm makes these feel special.

They work as Cucumber Tea Sandwiches , Tea Party Food , or quick Appetizer Sandwiches for guests.

Prep Steps

Get your mise en place. Slice butter, zest lemon, and chop herbs first. Have your mandoline, paper towels, and a tray ready.

Save time by washing the cucumber while mixing the lemon herb butter. Trim crusts later. Keep bowls stacked to minimize washing.

Be careful with the mandoline. Use a guard. Keep fingers back. Keep chilled ingredients in the fridge at 40° F ( 4° C) or below for safety.

step-by-step Process

Make lemon herb butter. Mix 6 tbsp softened butter, 1 tsp lemon juice, 1/2 tsp zest, 2 tbsp dill, 1/4 tsp salt , and a crack of pepper. Chill briefly if too soft.
Wash and trim cucumber. Peel partly for a rustic look. Slice paper thin on mandoline.
Salt cucumber slices lightly and rest 10– 15 minutes to draw moisture. Blot dry with paper towels.
Trim bread crusts if desired. Flatten slices with a rolling pin for tidy sandwiches. Spread a thin even layer of butter.
Arrange 3 4 cucumber slices per sandwich. Season lightly. Top with bread, butter side down.
Wrap and chill 10– 15 minutes to set. Cut into triangles for classic Classic British Tea Sandwiches .

Visual cues: cucumbers should look translucent and dry. Butter must be thin and even. Sandwich should hold together when pressed lightly.

Pro Tips

Use a mandoline for uniform slices. If you lack one, a very sharp knife works fine. Flatten bread so the spread melds into the crumb. Chill before cutting for clean edges.

Common mistakes: over salting, over buttering, and skipping the blotting step. These cause soggy sandwiches.

make-ahead: you can assemble and chill up to 2 hours before serving. Keep chilled until plated.

Honestly, these are fab as Lemon Herb Cucumber Sandwiches , Finger Sandwiches for Afternoon Tea , or Easy Picnic Finger Foods .

I once packed a tray for a friend’s brunch. Everyone raved. Try these for a light, elegant bite.

Serving Suggestions

I love serving Cucumber Sandwiches on a chilled platter. Keep them neat and cut into triangles. They look like proper Classic British Tea Sandwiches .

Pair with a pot of Earl Grey or Darjeeling. For a party, add chilled Champagne. These are perfect Tea Party Food bites. They also work as Appetizer Sandwiches for brunch.

Try stacking small mixed greens on the side. Fresh fruit or chilled asparagus brighten the plate. For picnics, they join Easy Picnic Finger Foods beautifully.

Storage Tips

If not eating right away, wrap sandwiches tightly. Then chill for up to 2 hours . This keeps them fresh and tidy.

To avoid sogginess, blot cucumber well. Salt then rest for 10– 15 minutes before assembly. This step is crucial.

Freezing is not recommended. Bread gets soggy and cucumbers go limp. Honestly, you lose the delicate texture.

To reheat, don’t. These are best cold. If you must, keep fillings minimal.

Variations

For a creamier bite, try cream cheese and dill. That creates lovely Cucumber Tea Sandwiches . For seafood fans, add smoked salmon.

Need vegan? Use vegan butter or herbed vegan cream cheese. These are great Vegetarian Tea Sandwich Recipes options.

Swap herbs by season. Spring loves dill and chives. Summer invites mint or basil. Lemon zest keeps it bright for Lemon Herb Cucumber Sandwiches .

Nutrition Basics

Each full sandwich has about 260 calories. Fat and carbs come mainly from butter and bread. Protein is modest at around 4 grams.

Key benefits include hydration from cucumber. It’s low calorie and refreshing. Herbs add antioxidants and a flavor punch.

I once sliced cucumbers for an oak-table tea. My hands cramped. Lesson learned: use a mandoline. The result was worth it.

Guests kept saying these were the best Tea Party Sandwiches and Finger Sandwiches for Afternoon Tea they’d tried.

Keep it simple. Embrace the little flaws. These sandwiches bring calm to busy days. Try them soon you’ll smile when someone takes a bite.

Cucumber Tea Sandwiches Irresistible LemonHerb Finger Sandwiches

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I stop cucumber sandwiches from getting soggy?

Drawing out moisture is the single best trick: thinly slice the cucumber, sprinkle with a little salt, let the slices sit 10 15 minutes, then blot completely dry with paper towels.

Spread a thin, even layer of lemon-herb butter (or cream cheese) on the bread first that fat barrier helps keep moisture from soaking into the crumb. Also chill the assembled sandwiches briefly before cutting; a short rest in the fridge firms everything up for cleaner slices.

Can I make Cucumber Sandwiches ahead of time for a party?

You can assemble them and keep chilled for 1 2 hours before serving without much loss of texture, which is handy for afternoon tea or a picnic. For longer prep, make the lemon-herb butter and slice the cucumbers in advance (drain and pat dry, then refrigerate in a single layer between paper towels), and only butter and assemble the bread shortly before guests arrive.

Avoid freezing assembled sandwiches they’ll become watery and lose their delicate texture.

What's the best way to slice cucumbers paper thin if I don't have a mandoline?

If you don’t own a mandoline, use a very sharp chef’s knife and a steady hand: slice slowly, keeping the cucumber steady and making long, even strokes. Chill the cucumber briefly before slicing it firms up and is easier to cut thinly and consider using a vegetable peeler for slightly wider, paper-thin ribbons.

If you do use a mandoline, wear a cut-resistant glove and use the guard for safety.

What are easy variations or substitutions for Classic Cucumber Tea Sandwiches?

For a simple twist, swap the lemon-herb butter for soft cream cheese mixed with dill or chives, or add smoked salmon and capers for a richer tea-time treat. Vegan or lighter options work well: try vegan butter or a whipped herbed yogurt (or strained Greek yogurt) and whole-grain or gluten-free bread.

You can also tweak herbs chives, tarragon or parsley all play nicely with cucumber if you don’t have fresh dill.

Are cucumber sandwiches healthy what about calories and dietary concerns?

A typical full sandwich from this recipe is estimated around 260 kcal, with most calories coming from butter and bread; using lighter spreads or lower-calorie breads reduces that significantly.

For more fibre and nutrients choose whole-grain bread, swap some butter for Greek yogurt or mashed avocado for healthy fats, and watch added salt if you’re sodium-sensitive.

They’re naturally vegetarian and easily made vegan or gluten-free with appropriate substitutes, so they suit a range of dietary needs at a garden party or afternoon tea.

Classic Cucumber Tea Sandwiches Light Lemonherb

Classic LemonHerb Cucumber Sandwiches My GoTo Tea Sandwiches Recipe Card

0.0 / 5 (0 Review)

Preparation time:35 Mins

Cooking time:0

Servings:6 full sandwiches (12 finger sandwiches)

Instructions:

Prepare the lemon herb butter by combining softened butter, lemon juice, lemon zest, chopped dill or chives, salt, and pepper in a bowl; mix until smooth and taste to adjust seasoning. Refrigerate briefly if too soft to spread.
Wash the cucumber and trim the ends. Peel if skin is thick or waxed (or leave half peeled for a rustic look). Slice cucumber paper thin with a mandoline or a very sharp knife.
Lightly salt the cucumber slices in a bowl and let them sit 10 15 minutes to draw out excess moisture. Gently blot the slices dry with paper towels to remove liquid and prevent soggy sandwiches.
If desired, trim crusts from the bread for a classic tea-sandwich presentation. Optionally flatten each slice with a rolling pin for a finer crumb. Spread a thin, even layer of the lemon herb butter over one side of each slice.
Assemble sandwiches by arranging cucumber slices in a single even layer on the buttered side of half the slices (slightly overlapping; about 3 4 thin slices per sandwich). Season lightly with a pinch of salt and a grind of black pepper and add microgreens if using. Top with remaining bread slices, butter side down.
Press sandwiches gently, wrap in plastic, and chill 10 15 minutes to set for cleaner cuts. Remove plastic, cut crusts if not already removed, then slice each sandwich into halves or triangles (for 12 finger sandwiches, cut each into two triangles). Serve immediately or keep chilled up to 2 hours before serving.